Enterprise journal Wirtschaftswoche encapsulated the issue with a latest cowl: Vladimir Putin controls Germany the way in which a vendor controls a junkie. Pure fuel is the drug of alternative.
The shrewdness of Putin’s technique is evident now Russian tanks are rolling. Efficient sanctions would ban Russian power exports, or funds for them through the worldwide banking system. However that extreme blow to Russia’s resource-dependent economic system would badly damage Germans. The power coverage errors of their leaders are woefully obvious.
Chancellor Olaf Scholz has solely halted a second pipeline, Nord Stream 2, now that Russia is invading jap Ukraine. This is able to have doubled the capability of imports to 110bn cubic metres.
The primary Nord Stream pipeline system already provides two-thirds of Germany’s imported power. Half Germany’s 40m households preserve heat utilizing pure fuel, 97 per cent of it from abroad.
Scholz’s predecessors Gerhard Schröder, a buddy of Putin who’s now a Gazprom board nominee, and Angela Merkel steered Germany in direction of its dependancy. The renewables endorsed by Merkel offered 44 per cent of the nation’s power technology within the first half of 2021, based on official information. However she additionally ordered the closure of nuclear vegetation.
Fossil fuels produce the majority of Russia’s overseas revenue. Final yr, Russia’s pure fuel exports introduced in $55.5bn — principally from Europe. That was the best since 2013. European pure fuel costs have quintupled over the past yr. Tellingly, the futures curve has now flattened, says consultancy Rystad Vitality. Fears of Russian provide disruption have forestalled the everyday spring and summer time value slide.
Annexing the entire of Ukraine would strengthen Russia’s grip on Western Europe’s power provide. Ukraine would not be a transit nation in a position to reduce off exports through its ageing pipeline system.
Within the quick time period Putin has the whip hand. Autocrats can ponder hardship for his or her compatriots extra cheerfully than democratic politicians. The west is unlikely to impose a full export ban on fuel. Germany has few different power decisions. Typical sources, reminiscent of coal and nuclear, are politically unpalatable with the Inexperienced Get together, a member of Scholz’s coalition authorities.
Longer-term, Germany should construct up various fuel provides. It ought to lastly heed US warnings and mothball Nord Stream 2 completely. It ought to spend money on terminals to import liquefied pure fuel. It has none working and just one below building.
The simpler, cheaper alternative could be to open Nord Stream 2 after the renewed Russian invasion has light into latest historical past. Politicians would invoice this as “the normalisation of relations”. Pretending suppliers are buddies is one hallmark of the addict.
The Lex group is serious about listening to extra from readers. Please inform us what you consider Germany’s dependency on Russian fuel within the feedback part beneath.
