Wednesday, February 23, 2022
Quotation Counts By Area: Is Con Regulation 5 Instances Extra Vital Than Tax?
Following up on my earlier submit, Leiter: Quotation Counts Fluctuate By Area—Tax Is nineteenth Amongst 21 Topic Areas (Aug. 17, 2021): Brian Leiter (Chicago), Quotation Counts Fluctuate By Area, 2016-2020 Version:
This is an up to date model of a submit from final summer season, now utilizing the Sisk knowledge for the interval 2016-2020. …
Of the ten most-cited school within the U.S. within the final Sisk research, eight labored not less than partly in constitutional legislation. Certainly, constitutional legislation is essentially the most high-citation discipline, though company, legislation & economics, prison legislation & process, legislation & know-how, and mental property additionally get cited loads. In contrast, tax, proof, and well being legislation, amongst others, are low-citation fields. 300 cites in a five-year interval will get you into the highest 5 in tax, however not wherever near the highest 20 in constitutional legislation (perhaps the highest 50?).
Stephen Bainbridge (UCLA), Quotation Counts By Area of Experience–Is the Constitutional Regulation Actually All That Vital?:
Constitutional legislation is ranked #1 (4,880 citations). Tax is twenty fourth (880) and proof is final (twenty sixth; 630 citations). I get that almost all authorized teachers assume constitutional legislation is horny. However is it actually 5 occasions as essential as taxation? Is it actually 8 occasions as essential as proof?
I believe it speaks to the skewed values of the authorized academy. The bread and butter of authorized follow, which impacts extra individuals’s lives, get quick shrift.
https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2022/02/citation-counts-by-field-is-con-law-5-times-more-important-than-tax.html
