Most enterprise house owners don’t wish to ask their staff to work time beyond regulation, however generally it’s essential when the surprising occurs. To keep away from any misunderstandings between you and your group, it’s necessary to handle the query: Is obligatory time beyond regulation authorized?
Should you’re an worker who isn’t conscious of obligatory time beyond regulation legal guidelines, it’s possible you’ll assume you possibly can refuse time beyond regulation work due to labor laws prohibiting obligatory time beyond regulation.
On the flip aspect, it’s possible you’ll be a busy employer who can’t persuade their staff to select up any time beyond regulation shifts. You aren’t well-versed in obligatory time beyond regulation and also you assume your arms are legally tied.
The actual fact is that employers can oblige staff to work time beyond regulation hours, and staff may be fired for refusing to work obligatory time beyond regulation. However there are, in fact, federal businesses tasked with regulating labor and time beyond regulation — and there are methods to stop obligatory time beyond regulation as a lot as potential.
So, let’s focus on what obligatory time beyond regulation is and what it means for employers and staff.

Do not forget that this data just isn’t authorized recommendation. When doubtful, at all times seek the advice of an employment legal professional together with your particular questions on labor regulation compliance and penalties.
What’s obligatory time beyond regulation?
Obligatory time beyond regulation happens when employers require hourly staff to work greater than 40 hours in a workweek. The FLSA (Truthful Labor Requirements Act) requires employers to pay their staff time and a half, or 1.5 occasions, their hourly wage for each time beyond regulation hour. Time beyond regulation exemptions do exist for workers who’re paid a set wage of at the very least $684 every week, and whose duties meet the chief, administrative, or skilled duties assessments outlined within the FLSA.
Is obligatory time beyond regulation authorized?
Sure, obligatory time beyond regulation is authorized, and usually, staff can’t refuse to work time beyond regulation. The FLSA doesn’t put a restrict on what number of hours of time beyond regulation an worker can work — it solely stipulates that employers should pay minimal wage for normal hours and time beyond regulation charges when an worker works over 40 hours every week.
There are, nonetheless, a couple of situations the place employers can’t legally mandate pressured time beyond regulation hours. Let’s take a look at a couple of examples.
Not if it violates the phrases of an employment contract
If an employer clearly outlines their time beyond regulation hours and off-the-clock insurance policies in an employment contract or contractually binding handbook and violates these phrases, an worker might have a case for damages for breach of contract.
Have in mind: Whereas employers typically require administrative, govt, {and professional} salaried staff to signal employment contracts, it’s extra frequent to require an hourly worker to learn and signal an worker handbook.
Employers can implement employment contracts for hourly staff, although, and so they also can use contractually binding language of their worker handbooks with a authorized clause on the finish for an worker to signal. It’s necessary for employers and staff to concentrate to the authorized nature of their worker settlement — particularly concerning time beyond regulation phrases.
Not if it poses a well being or security hazard
Obligatory time beyond regulation is against the law if it poses a well being or security threat and clearly violates the OSHA (Occupational Security and Well being Administration) Normal Obligation Clause.
OSHA can cite an employer for a violation if all of those parts are current:
- “The employer didn’t hold the office freed from a hazard to which staff of that employer had been uncovered;
- The hazard was acknowledged;
- The hazard was inflicting or was more likely to trigger demise or severe bodily hurt; and
- There was a possible and helpful methodology to right the hazard.”
Meaning if an worker feels obligatory time beyond regulation would put dangerously fatigued staff in danger — and the employer takes no motion to keep away from the danger after it’s flagged — an worker can file a grievance leading to an on-site OSHA inspection.
Not in case you are inadequately compensated for time beyond regulation work
Employers could possibly be vulnerable to unlawful obligatory time beyond regulation in the event that they don’t compensate staff adequately. Typically employers make frequent wage errors or implement an time beyond regulation wage threshold for non-exempt staff who truly qualify for time beyond regulation.
Workers could possibly be lacking out on required time beyond regulation compensation if their employer has:
- Misclassified them as exempt staff. In line with FLSA laws, exempt staff need to go three assessments with a view to be exempt from time beyond regulation pay. First, they need to have duties which can be administrative, govt, or skilled in nature. Additionally they need to be paid a wage, and that wage can’t be lower than $684.
- Deducted time beyond regulation pay due to poor efficiency. An employer can solely deduct pay when an worker misses two or extra consecutive days of labor for causes apart from incapacity, sickness, or day without work. Employers also can deduct pay for main security violations or when staff are suspended from work for misconduct.
- Deducted cost for relaxation breaks to keep away from time beyond regulation pay. So long as staff work a sure variety of hours a day, employers need to pay them for breaks of 15 or 20 minutes.
- Not paid time beyond regulation for obligatory coaching throughout work hours.
Not you probably have a household emergency
Obligatory time beyond regulation just isn’t authorized if an employer requires it for an worker who has a household or medical emergency and is on go away due to it.
The FMLA offers eligible staff as much as 12 weeks of unpaid go away a yr, entitles them to advantages throughout that point, and ensures they will return to the identical or an equal job on the finish of their go away interval. Meaning they’re not topic to obligatory time beyond regulation whereas they’re on go away.
Not in case you are a member of a union
Beneath the Nationwide Labor Relations Act (NLRA), which presents protections for union staff, employers might not be allowed to implement obligatory time beyond regulation if they’ve come to an time beyond regulation settlement with staff on account of collective bargaining.
Most staff have the precise to prepare, share data, signal petitions, and search to enhance their wages and dealing situations by way of unionization, even when they work in a non-union office.
If staff select a union to signify them in a collective bargaining settlement, an employer is required to fulfill them to discount “in good religion” about wages, hours, or working situations, together with discussions about obligatory time beyond regulation.
Methods to keep away from obligatory time beyond regulation: ideas for employers
Whereas obligatory time beyond regulation work has benefits like elevated pay and productiveness, an excessive amount of time beyond regulation can include unintended penalties.
When staff really feel that time beyond regulation is one thing ‘mandated’ and out of their management, it could possibly result in elevated stress, decreased morale and belief, and a rise in turnover and resignations.
An extra of obligatory time beyond regulation also can inspire disgruntled staff to take authorized motion towards an organization in the event that they see match. Right here’s how one can keep away from time beyond regulation and its penalties in your office.
Hiring part-time staff or short-term employees
Whether or not you’re the proprietor of a roofing firm or a boutique salon, you possible have a busy season. Christmas time is usually a hectic time of yr for retail companies, for instance, and summer season tends to usher in extra visitors for ice cream retailers.
Should you can plan and predict for these seasons forward of time by hiring part-time staff, short-term employees, or seasonal staff, you possibly can assist cut back your reliance on obligatory time beyond regulation throughout busy intervals.
Monitor staffing shortages to stop time beyond regulation
Staffing shortages typically put the burden of additional work — and the potential of obligatory time beyond regulation — on different staff. Preserve observe of your staffing shortages to get a greater sense of how one can handle them.
Perhaps you will have sufficient obligatory time beyond regulation hours to justify hiring one other full-time or part-time worker. Otherwise you don’t have sufficient hours, however you have trainable staff who can tackle extra tasks. Typically stopping time beyond regulation is a simply matter of getting inventive together with your staffing choices.
Talk clearly together with your staff
For some employers, avoiding obligatory time beyond regulation may be prevented with one thing so simple as clear communication.
Create a tradition of clear communication together with your staff by at all times being open and sincere concerning the chance of obligatory time beyond regulation sooner or later, and encourage them to talk up after they have issues.
When you understand {that a} busy time of yr is arising or have an in depth challenge on the horizon, speaking to your staff and bringing them into the planning course of may help you keep away from the necessity for an excessive amount of obligatory time beyond regulation and the necessity to make surprising time beyond regulation calls for in your staff.
Methods to keep away from obligatory time beyond regulation: ideas for workers
Obligatory time beyond regulation can seem to be one thing non-exempt staff don’t have any say over. However staff who take the time to teach themselves on firm insurance policies, be taught their rights, and negotiate time beyond regulation phrases with their employer may help create a office that’s freed from an excessive amount of time beyond regulation.
Learn the corporate coverage on obligatory time beyond regulation
Should you’re a employee who’s not exempt from obligatory time beyond regulation, you should definitely learn and perceive your organization’s insurance policies on time beyond regulation, together with obligatory time beyond regulation. In case your employer’s insurance policies on time beyond regulation are unclear, be sure to ask them clarifying questions like:
- Do you will have a compulsory time beyond regulation coverage?
- How do you compensate staff for obligatory time beyond regulation?
- How a lot discover do you give staff earlier than you implement obligatory time beyond regulation?
- How do you observe obligatory time beyond regulation hours?
- What do you do if obligatory time beyond regulation poses a well being or security hazard?
In case your employer doesn’t have a solution, or their reply conflicts with the FLSA or OSHA laws, deliver this up with them immediately.
Learn the state legal guidelines
Whereas time beyond regulation hours are outlined within the FLSA as any hours labored over a 40-hour workweek, every state has its personal set of time beyond regulation laws. For instance, California’s time beyond regulation necessities state that staff who work time beyond regulation need to be compensated with a minimal of:
- “One and one-half occasions the worker’s common price of pay for all hours labored in extra of eight hours as much as and together with 12 hours in any workday, and for the primary eight hours labored on the seventh consecutive day of labor in a workweek; and
- Double the worker’s common price of pay for all hours labored in extra of 12 hours in any workday and for all hours labored in extra of eight on the seventh consecutive day of labor in a workweek”
Go to Homebase’s state labor legal guidelines hub to entry an employment regulation information on your state.
Negotiate time beyond regulation phrases in the course of the hiring course of
Workers can use the hiring course of to barter the phrases of their contract, and time beyond regulation phrases aren’t any exception. If you understand that you simply’re non-exempt from time beyond regulation pay, have studied your organization’s worker insurance policies, and researched state time beyond regulation legal guidelines, you possibly can negotiate:
- Time beyond regulation compensation: How a lot your employer pays you for obligatory time beyond regulation.
- Time beyond regulation discover: How a lot discover your employer ought to provide you with earlier than it’s important to work obligatory time beyond regulation.
- Compensatory time: That is day without work given instead of time beyond regulation compensation. An worker can ask their employer to present them “comp time” off as an alternative of getting time beyond regulation pay.
- Compensation for childcare, commuting, or different bills that come on account of obligatory time beyond regulation.
Keep in mind: Realizing your time beyond regulation rights can forestall an employer from negotiating away what you’re legally entitled to.
Negotiate a cutoff for time beyond regulation hours
Employers ought to respect an worker’s want for relaxation and work-life stability, so we encourage staff to barter a cutoff for time beyond regulation hours in the course of the hiring course of, too.
If, for instance, you’re feeling that working greater than 60 hours every week will have an effect on your efficiency and pose a threat to your well being, ask your employer if they will clearly stipulate a cap on time beyond regulation hours in your contract or worker settlement.
Homebase’s function in stopping pointless time beyond regulation

Stopping obligatory time beyond regulation isn’t at all times potential, however with the precise planning and methods in place, you possibly can keep away from pointless time beyond regulation.
We created Homebase’s suite of instruments to assist enterprise house owners streamline worker scheduling, time beyond regulation monitoring, and hiring and onboarding to allow them to keep compliant with time beyond regulation legal guidelines and hold obligatory time beyond regulation to a minimal.
Higher worker scheduling
Employers may need to implement obligatory time beyond regulation after they plan week-to-week and have restricted visibility on who’s working and who will want day without work for the month forward.
Homebase helps companies keep away from this pitfall with automated schedules you possibly can construct weeks prematurely — and your group can plan or reschedule their shifts forward of time.
Automated monitoring of time beyond regulation wages
When employers use guide time monitoring and payroll methods that don’t hold them up to date about what number of hours every worker has labored in every week, it’s straightforward to slide into obligatory time beyond regulation with out even realizing it.
Homebase’s free time clock syncs together with your payroll timesheets to maintain you on prime of an worker’s common hours, break hours, and time beyond regulation hours.
Improved hiring processes for added staff
For busy enterprise house owners and groups making an attempt to keep away from an excessive amount of time beyond regulation, the considered taking time to rent new staff generally feels overwhelming, even when new hires will assist cut back obligatory time beyond regulation.
Get entry to personalized or pre-written job description templates, prime on-line job boards, an applicant monitoring system, and applicant screening multi function place with Homebase hiring and onboarding so it can save you time and trouble when hiring new staff.
You’ll be able to have obligatory time beyond regulation and a contented work atmosphere
Whereas obligatory time beyond regulation could make employers uneasy and staff aggravated, it doesn’t need to trigger a rift in your group.
When employers create a tradition of listening, openness, and transparency round troublesome points and take the time to assist staff perceive why obligatory time beyond regulation is usually inevitable, they’re extra more likely to really feel they’re on the identical group as their bosses, even in powerful conditions.
FAQs about obligatory time beyond regulation
Can an employer drive you to work time beyond regulation?
An employer can drive you to work time beyond regulation. In line with the FLSA, they will require you to work any hours over a daily workweek, which is 40 hours. If an employer requires you to work time beyond regulation, they’re legally obliged to pay you time and a half, or 1.5 occasions your common hourly pay price.
Are there exceptions to working time beyond regulation?
The FLSA presents exemptions from obligatory time beyond regulation to govt, administrative, skilled, and outdoors gross sales staff. To qualify for time beyond regulation exemptions, staff’ job descriptions need to go the duties assessments outlined within the FLSA for every of these roles, and a job title alone doesn’t rely. Employers additionally need to pay exempt staff a minimal of:
- $684 every week for govt, administrative, {and professional} staff
- $684 every week or $27.30 an hour for laptop professionals
- $107,432 a yr for extremely compensated staff, or staff who, in line with the IRS, make $130,000 from the employer who sponsors their 401(ok) or who owns greater than 5% curiosity of their firm.
Can staff who refuse to work time beyond regulation be fired?
Sure, an worker who just isn’t exempt from time beyond regulation guidelines and who refuses to work time beyond regulation may be fired. so long as they’re not terminated for an unlawful motive. An worker could have a case for wrongful termination in the event that they really feel they had been truly fired primarily based on:
- Discrimination: Completely different or poor remedy primarily based on race, gender, nationwide origin, incapacity, age, being pregnant, medical background, faith, or genetic data
- Retaliation: An motion taken towards an worker as a result of they filed a grievance about discrimination or harassment
Can an employer require you to work time beyond regulation with out discover?
Sure, an employer can require you to work time beyond regulation with out discover. They can’t, nonetheless, ask you to work off-the-clock with out violating the FLSA laws.
Employers ought to remember the fact that if an worker qualifies for time beyond regulation hours, they qualify for time beyond regulation pay, and employers ought to carefully monitor that they accomplish their duties inside the time beyond regulation hours. If an worker will get paid hourly and their duties don’t meet the necessities for time beyond regulation pay exemption, employers need to pay them time and a half for any time beyond regulation hours.