TaxProf Weblog

Tax Prof Weblog op-ed:  The Financial Worth of Legislation Clinic Authorized Help by Robert Kuehn (Washington College):

Every year regulation college clinics present free authorized help to tens of hundreds of shoppers, most of whom would in any other case go unrepresented. The work of clinic college students and college permits shoppers to advance or defend their rights or get hold of help or funds to which they’re entitled, help that’s in some ways invaluable to shoppers and their communities. Whereas the advantages of clinic work might be tough to monetize, it’s doable to estimate the greenback worth of the tens of millions of hours of free authorized help regulation clinics present every year to people, governmental companies, and non-profit organizations. As defined under, regulation clinic college students alone present tens of tens of millions of {dollars} in professional bono authorized companies every year.

Throughout tutorial 12 months 2020-21, 114,520 J.D. college students had been enrolled in ABA-approved regulation faculties.[i] The ABA ceased amassing knowledge on regulation clinic course enrollment in 2016. However within the six years prior, faculties reported that enrollment every year of their clinics (“seats crammed”) was between 85% to 76% of the whole variety of seats obtainable for enrollment (“seats obtainable”), lowering in proportion every year from 2011 to 2016.[ii] As a result of there isn’t any proof of a noticeable enhance in enrollment in experiential programs since 2016,[iii] an affordable assumption is that of the 32,062 reported seats obtainable in 2020-21, round 24,000 college students (75% of 32,062) truly enrolled in one of many college’s clinics (21% of all J.D.s). Solely a handful of clinics cost a payment for his or her companies and roughly 10% of the clinics within the 2019-20 Heart for the Examine of Utilized Authorized Training (CSALE) survey may help some for-profit organizations, although even these are typically of restricted means.[iv] After excluding these classes of clinic work, it’s affordable to conservatively assume that in 2020-21, roughly 22,000 clinic college students supplied their free help simply to people, authorities entities, and non-profits.

The CSALE survey collected info on 950 regulation college clinics. The median variety of credit awarded for simply the clinic scholar’s discipline or casework (i.e., non-classroom exercise) on behalf of shoppers was 3.5, with every credit score representing 42.5 hours of labor underneath the minimal commonplace set by the ABA. The typical clinic scholar, subsequently, labored 149 hours in the course of the time period on the casework portion of their regulation clinic course. Thus, in the course of the 2020-21 tutorial 12 months, the 22,000 college students in regulation college clinics are estimated to have supplied roughly 3,278,000 hours of free authorized help to people, authorities entities, and non-profits.

The Supreme Court docket held that in awarding authorized charges to prevailing events, paralegals and regulation clerks are to be awarded charges at market charges, and courts additionally award charges for comparable clinic scholar work at market charges.[v] One nationwide survey of typical billing charges for paralegals discovered that regulation corporations cost their shoppers between $100-$200 per hour, with most falling within the median of that vary;[vi] one other survey discovered that charges for non-lawyers throughout states ranged from $99 to $220 per hour.[vii] If regulation scholar work is conservatively valued at a market fee of $100 per hour, as instances assist,[viii] clinic college students are estimated to have supplied over $325 million in free authorized help in 2020-21.

Alternatively valuing scholar time on the decrease prevailing wage fee additionally reveals the big financial worth of clinic help. Wages for regulation college students differ extensively, from round $20-25 per hour in some areas and for some forms of regulation workplaces and shoppers, to $100 per hour for summer time work at elite regulation corporations. There isn’t a Bureau of Labor Statistics median wage for regulation scholar employment. Nevertheless, the median wage for paralegals and authorized assistants is $27.03 per hour.[ix] Utilizing this decrease valuation of scholar time, regulation clinic college students nonetheless supplied over $88.5 million in free authorized help in 2020-21.

An Affiliation of American Legislation Faculties survey of regulation faculties additionally sought to worth scholar professional bono companies. It reported 4.7 million hours in donated authorized companies by college students throughout tutorial 12 months 2018-19, valued on the common fee for volunteer time of $25.43 per hour, for a complete worth of $119 million.[x] The survey solely obtained info from 103 faculties and the questionnaire didn’t outline or restrict what a college may depend as professional bono service or escape hours by the kind of service reported (i.e., regulation clinic, externship, or scholar group actions). [xi]

Public service is a core worth of authorized training[xii] and professional bono authorized actions a skilled accountability of regulation professors.[xiii] Though faculties typically bemoan their prices, regulation clinics play a main function in fulfilling these beliefs by offering native communities with tens of millions of hours of much-needed authorized help and lots of of tens of millions of {dollars} in free companies every year.

[i] ABA, 2021 Commonplace 509 Info Report Information Overview, https://www.americanbar.org/content material/dam/aba/administrative/legal_education_and_admissions_to_the_bar/statistics/2021/2021-509-enrollment-summary-report.pdf.

[ii] ABA, 509 Required Disclosures─Curriculum, https://www.abarequireddisclosures.org/Disclosure509.aspx.

[iii] Robert R Kuehn, Implementation of the ABA’s New Experiential Coaching Requirement: Extra Whimper Than Bang (Spring 2021),  https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3837606.

[iv] Robert R. Kuehn, Margaret Reuter & David A. Santacroce, 2019-20 Survey of Utilized Authorized Training (excluding clinics described as entrepreneurship/small enterprise, mental property, know-how, and transactional), https://uploads-ssl.webflow.com/5d8cde48c96867b8ea8c6720/5f8e46e59e39d4dc82e70a54_Reportpercent20onpercent202019-20percent20CSALEpercent20Survey.10.19.20.pdf.

[v] Missouri v. Jenkins, 491 U.S. 274, 285 (1989), https://supreme.justia.com/instances/federal/us/491/274.

[vi] CosmoLex, How A lot Ought to Our Legislation Agency Invoice for Paralegal Work?, https://www.cosmolex.com/resource-center/running-a-law-office/how-much-should-our-law-firm-bill-for-paralegal-work.

[vii] Clio, 2021 Authorized Traits Report 63, https://www.clio.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/2021-Authorized-Traits-Report-Oct-26.pdf.

[viii] See, e.g., League of Wilderness Defenders/Blue Mountains Biodiversity Mission v. U.S. Forest Serv., 305 F. Supp.3d 1156 (D.Or. 2018); Davis v. Lancatser, No. 4:13CV1638 HEA (E.D. Mo. Jan. 18, 2019), https://casetext.com/case/davis-v-lancatser.

[ix] U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook – Paralegals and Authorized Assistants, https://www.bls.gov/ooh/authorized/paralegals-and-legal-assistants.htm#tab-1.

[x] Affiliation of American Legislation Faculties, AALS Legislation Pupil Professional Bono Hours Survey Report (2019), https://www.aals.org/aals-newsroom/2019-aals-law-student-pro-bono-hours-survey-report.

[xi] Affiliation of American Legislation Faculties, AALS Legislation Pupil Professional Bono Hours Survey Questions (2019), https://www.aals.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/AALS-Legislation-Pupil-Professional-Bono-Hours-Survey-Questions-2019.pdf.

[xii] Affiliation of American Legislation Faculties, Legislation Pupil Professional Bono Contributions (2019), https://aalsweb.wufoo.com/varieties/w1fuc2201qpe1pe.

[xiii] Affiliation of American Legislation Faculties, Legislation Professors within the Discharge of Moral and Skilled Tasks, https://www.aals.org/about/handbook/good-practices/ethics.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2022/05/kuehn-the-economic-value-of-law-clinic-legal-assistance.html