TaxProf Weblog

Michael Conklin (Angelo State; Google Scholar), Legislation Faculty Rankings and Political Ideology: Measuring the Conservative Penalty and Liberal Bonus with Up to date 2023 Rankings Information:

In 2020, novel analysis was carried out to measure whether or not, and to what extent, conservative regulation colleges are punished and liberal regulation colleges are rewarded within the U.S. Information & World Report peer rankings. The examine discovered a drastic conservative penalty and liberal bonus that amounted to a distinction within the peer rankings of twenty-eight spots. This Article updates the analysis utilizing the most recent political affiliation knowledge and the latest 2023 rankings knowledge. The up to date outcomes produce an astounding thirty-two-place distinction within the peer rankings attributable to political ideology. This enhance from the 2020 analysis elicits dialogue concerning the results of current societal modifications in polarization and civility. 

A dialogue on how this disparity within the rankings might perpetuate an absence of ideological range in authorized academia can be mentioned. The hurt to professors, college students, and society at giant from such an absence of ideological range in regulation colleges is mentioned. Lastly, this Article concludes by proposing a easy answer to bypass this manifestation of ideological bias in authorized academia.

Conclusion
This Article produces a robust, cumulative case for the existence of ideological discrimination in regulation college usually and, extra particularly, within the peer rankings. The conclusion of ideological discrimination is additional strengthened when the outcomes of this analysis are thought-about in tandem with the compelling proof of ideological discrimination in hiring regulation professors—a choice by which regulation college deans additionally play a big position. As a result of peer rankings are the main issue within the total rankings, this anti-conservative bias additionally inflicts a conservative penalty there as nicely, though much less extreme.

Whereas the magnitude of ideological bias found on this examine could also be shocking, the notion that regulation college deans—consciously or in any other case—apply a conservative penalty and liberal bonus when rating regulation colleges isn’t a surprise. The political ideologies of regulation college deans are probably comparable with these of regulation college college—that are extremely disproportionately liberal. Political ideology is a big issue that impacts how individuals interpret data. Simply as a conservative might view a liberal regulation college with heightened skepticism, it seems liberal regulation college deans view conservative regulation colleges on this identical means. Current polarizing occasions such because the January 6 Capitol assault, COVID-19, and the Black Lives Matter motion are ultimate candidates for why this ideological bias has elevated because the 2020 examine.

This Article paperwork the hurt to conservative professors, regulation college students, and society at giant from ideological bias in regulation college rankings. Luckily, there’s a easy answer to the issue. Eradicating the peer rating from the general rankings calculation will cut back such hurt whereas offering the advantages of higher informing potential regulation college students, decreasing inefficiencies within the hiring market, and contributing to higher ideological range in regulation colleges and authorized scholarship.

https://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2022/04/measuring-the-conservative-penalty-and-liberal-bonus-with-updated-2023-rankings-data.html